A unkempt woman, with hair graying, shoulders rounded and eyes rimmed with thick glasses, reads a newspaper on a subway car in New York City. She is colored. Her skirt is in rags, one toe shows through a shoe, an elbow pushes the lining of her sleeve into sight; perhaps she has just left her mop and pail in some downtown office building. Turning the pages hastily, she seems to be hunting for a particular place. At last she stops. Her forefinger runs up and down the columns. She is looking at the financial page. Finding an item, she gazes closely at it for a moment, and then throws the paper onto the seat beside her. She has a dejected look. Apparently she is through with the paper.
She has been looking for "the numbers." The numbers she wanted were the day's totals of bank exchanges and bank balances--announced each day by the Clearing House and published by the newspapers. On these she has been gambling. Suppose the exchanges were $793,482,450 and the balances $86,453,624. She is then interested in the number 936, because that is made up of the seventh and eighth digits, reading from the right, of the first, and the seventh digit of the second. She and many others are playing this game--a species of policy. If she has put her money, which may be only a few pennies, on 936 that day, she wins. Each day she looks forward to discovering what this combination is. It is the bright spot for her.
The stakes are high if she wins. She reaps 600 times what she wagers. If she wagers a nickel, she wins thirty dollars; if she wagers a quarter, she wins $150; a deposit of fifty cents will bring her $300. These stakes have lure; they are a king's stakes. They will make her rich for the moment. She does not consider the chances against her. She does not consider that she has never won and that only once did she ever hear of anybody winning. The bare possibility of capturing so much money makes her heart beat faster.
Since there are 999 numbers of three digits, or 1000 if we include 000, she seems to have about one chance in a thousand of winning. By the law of averages, she might play the same number daily for three years without a strike. The banker pays 600 times the sum wagered. He, therefore, seems to have a sure thing; barring lucky wins by large gamblers, he can't lose in the long run. That does not interest her, either.
All Harlem is ablaze ith "the numbers." People play it everywhere, in tenements, on street corners, in the backs of shops. "Bankers" organize it, promote it, encourage it. They send their runners into flats and stores. You give the runner the money you are betting, write your number on a slip of paper, and wait. If the number you chose is the one that wins next day, you get your money. Runners round up new business, stake off territory and canvass all the people they can reach. A person living in an apartment house may be the agent for that house. The names of these bankers are known in the neighborhood. One rides around in a $12,000 limousine and has a liveried chauffeur. Minor bankers abound; men and women, getting $200 capital start in the "numbers" business. Recently, it is said, white men have been trying to wrest the control of the game from blacks; a Jew who formerly used his talents in the hooch business is spoken of as the leader in this effort.
"Always out first with the bank clearing numbers" reads a placard advertising the New York Sun in Harlem. Inspiration for lucky numbers is got from every source. People get their numbers from dream books; fifteen or twenty cents will buy a dream book! and a dream about any topic listed in it has an appropriate number. Or two people exchange street addresses. "Ah'm gonna play it! Ah'm gonna play it !" says one, as he takes down the address of the other. They get their numbers from the numbers of hymns given out in church, from subway cars, from telephone numbers, from dates, from baseball scores, from the prices they pay for purchased articles, from the license tags of passing automobiles. By combining or rearranging these, or using them unchanged, they tempt fortune.
One trouble is, of course, that they don't always get what they win. Many a banker, finding that large sums have been won from him, avoids payment; his victim has no recourse, since the whole transaction is outside the law. The streets of Harlem are being walked by people looking for those who owe them money won at "the numbers." The New York Age, a colored weekly, published a story about one banker who skipped to Cuba with $100.000 taken from the Negroes of Harlem; it is common to win $12, $18 and $30 and not get it. This is only an exasperation of the extortion. The whole game, as it is staged, smells of exploitation.
GREAT number of Negroes have recently swarmed up from the South to swell the Negro colonies of Northern cities. Many of them are unfamiliar with city ways. They have become an invitation to the exploiter and the fakir--the gambling promoter, the necromancer, the fortune teller, the fake druggist, the quack doctor, and even more deliberate cheaters, such as the rent gouger. Living compactly in restricted areas, they supply a fertile field. Density of population is the fakir's paradise; it is the cheater's fairest opportunity for secrecy and success. There he can strike and hide, or be continuously lost in the moving mass of his fellow beings. And, credulous and child-like, the Negro peasant migrant has provided fresh opportunities in Northern cities for many forms of exploitation.
Black art flourishes in Harlem--and elsewhere in New York. Egyptian seers uncover hidden knowledge, Indian fortune-tellers reveal the future, sorcerers perform their mysteries. Feats of witchcraft are done daily. A towel for turban and a smart manner are enough to transform any Harlem colored man into a dispenser of magic to his profit.
Come with me into any little stationery store on Lenox or Seventh Avenues--the two main business thoroughfares of the district--and peep into the dream and mystery books there offered for sale. Some of these can be bought, as said, for fifteen or twenty cents; others cost a dollar. Here is one called Albertus Magnus. It is described as the "approved, verified, sympathetic and natural Egyptian secrets, or White and Black Art for Man, and Beast, revealing the Forbidden Knowledge and Mysteries of Ancient Philosophers." Another is Napoleon's own Oraculum and Book of Fate, containing the explanations of dreams and other mysteries consulted on every occasion by Napoleon himself.
Stop in front of a well-known drug store on Lenox Avenue. Here roots, herbs and barks are displayed in the window. "Devil's Shoestring" one of these is called; others are "Jim Shanks," "John Conqueror," "Rattlesnake Master," "Sacred Bark" and "Jesuits' Barlc." In curled forms, in powders, in spirally bunches, in thick lfttle knots, they lie there; they are sold as cures for various forms of illness. I was interested in knowing just what these were; so I asked the druggist. He showed me the United States Dispensatory. Some of the names in his window are local and folk names for plants growing in various parts of this country and elsewhere, and these plants are mentioned in the Dispensatory as being credited with cathartic, diaphoretic and other medicinal qualities. That is all very well; it does not mean that taking these roots and leaves home and boiling them and then drinking the water enables you to obtain the benefit ot those qualities. The plants have other qualities which come out in the water as well as those you want, and you get the essence of the whole, uhich may have quite other effects than those you anticipate. Again, no one can tell wLether these plants are really what they are represented to be or not. Their sale is under no supervision; they may be roots of saplings dug in the Bronx, or bark from cherry trees disguised.
In these matters the Negro is, in large measure, his own enemy. He is bringing his own simplicity to the help of those who would take advantage of him. No good can come from blinking the fact that the Negro is, by and large, the great exploitable race of the Western world. Many Negroes find it so easy to expect something wonderful to happen; eager for pleasure, they are sanguinely expectant that it awaits them around every corner. They have the child's love of phantasy, too; they would escape from the harsh realities of a world in which they are not treated very well.
In addition to all this, many of the uneducated majority have a deeply imbedded trust in the white man--a holdover from slavery. This lies at the root of much exploitation. The Negro comes to our Northern cities, and we think that he is ready to cope with the complexity of St. Louis, Chicago and New York City. He is not. To transplant him from Georgia to Lenox Avenue is not to change him on the train; often he is still the simple and innocent child of his Southern life.
I am not blithely cataloging the Negro here as the possessor of a "child-mind." That is the pet formula of pseudoscientific race detractors. The Negro has sufficiently proved--and this number of Survey Graphic is only further proof--that, given opportunities, he can rise to any heights. The simplicity, innocence and child-like qualities of some Negroes are due in large part to lack of education and to the lack of certain kinds of experiences. They have not been invited to play an aggressive role, or even to create beautiful things. They have been kept under the thumb of the whites. Their innocence is the sort that you will find among rural whites and "green" foreign immigrants; it is "peasant-mindedness" in part.
Neither the facts, nor the explanations of the facts, however, justify members of his own race, or whites, in taking advantage of the simplicity that lies around them.
THERE are ways in which the Negro is more deliberately exploited in Harlem than in other Northern cities. He is subject to being fleeced in rent; This is not a rhetorical flourish. It is cold fact. I am not here referring merely to high rents, to "what the traffic will bear." I am referring to extortion.
The Negro is gouged. Because he is a Negro, because he can be taken advantage of, because his racial position makes it possible to gouge him, he is gouged.
Hear John R. Davies, judge in the Mullicipal Court in Harlem, who sees colored tenants pass in streams before him, seeking relief: "It is common for colored tenants in Harlem to pay twice as much as white tenants for the same apartments. "
Hear Lillian Grant, acting chairman of the Mayor's Committee on Rent Profiteering, also white, who looks at the whole city and sees Harlem in the perspective of comparison: "Negroes pay exorbitant rents. Their situation is terrible."
Let us come to particulars. Sophie Ellerbee is a colored tenant worth knowing. She came into court the other day and told the judge that the white family preceding her in the apartment into which she had just moved had paid $50 a month; the corporation owning it svas asking her to pay $75 now. This increase she thought excessive. Her attorney requested that the owner be brought into court and required to divulge its income, expenses and investment (as it could be compelled to do under the law), and thus to show whether the rent was justified. The jury awarded Mrs. Ellerbee a $20 reduction from the sum asked. When the verdict was announced, the attorney for the owner, who was a colored lawyer, moved to have it set aside.
"This rent is justified," he said. "The colored district is crowded. These Negroes cannot go anywhere else. If they attempt to move into houses formerly occupied by whites, they should pay what the landlords ask. It is the law of supply and demand."
The judge, Jacob Panken, flamed at him. Judge Panken had seen many colored tenants come into court `with tales similar to that of Mrs. Ellerbee and he said:
"I agree that the verdict should be set aside, but for the purpose of securing Mrs. Ellerbee a still greater reduction in rent. Your own client has admitted that it is making $10,000 a year on a $30,000 investrnent. That is excessive. This rent is too large. And you, as a colored attorney, ought to be ashamed of yourself. You as a lawyer are helping colored and white landlords to prey on your own."
As the attorney left the court, embarrassed, cries of "Shame!" came to him from the Negro spectators in the room.
Other colored tenants were in court the same day. Through the services of a white lawyer twenty-one of these secured reductions varying from $10 to $23 below the rents asked. "It is pretty good evidence that the landlord knows he is charging excessive rents if he accepts a reduction voluntarily, without going to trial," said the attorney. The calendar of the Municipal Court in Harlem is crowded with the cases of colored tenants seeking relief. The white lawyer who acts as attorney for the West Harlem Tenants' League, an organization befriending tenants in that neighborhood, had 15 cases set down for trial on one day, 41 on another, 37 on another and 32 on another.
The National Urban League is an organization of white and colored social workers and others. It is interested in the welfare of city Negroes. The New York branch of the league studied rents paid by both white and colored people in blocks accomodating both in the spring of 1924. "We found that Negroes paid from 40 to 60 per cent higher rents than white people did for the same class of apartments," said Mr. Hubert, secretary of the Harlem office.
Through the courts, under the emergency New York state rent laws, relief can be secured. It is the families that do not go to court that continue to pay the unduly high rents. Unfortunately these are the vast majority. For every Mrs. Ellerbee there are many- other colored tenants who, through ignorance, inertia or the congestion of the court calendar, do not get relief. Obviously individual trials cannot be given every tenant who is charged too high rent in Harlem; the court of justice is not the remedy for an extensive economic practice.
Let us look for a moment at the growth of this situation. Fifteen years ago Harlem as it is today did not exist; the colored population then was much smaller than it is now. It has grown continuously, swollen by additions from without. As the colored area grew, it has pressed against contiguous white territories. Block after block gave way. Stubbornly each block yielded. White people did not want to see their neighborhoods turn black. First one street was set as the "dead line" (in the white parlance) of the Negro advance, and then another. Always there were outposts, colored families breaking over the bounds and invading territory hitherto exclusively white.
This situation is the paradise of the ruthless landlord, or rent charger. If you own an apartment house in Harlem, if you do not live in it, and if you want the largest profits you can get, you will open it to those tenants who will pay you most. These are the tenants who are most in need of it. The whites do not have to have it. They can go elsewhereÑ to other parts of the city, to the suburbs, or they can just keep ahead of the Negro invasion and move a few blocks away. The Negro cannot; he will not be given an apartment elsewhere, he cannot be easily accomodated. He can live only in a limited area, and that area grows only bit by bit. So he will pay what you askÑor; rather, he will agree to pay what you ask and then he will pay it if he can.
The profiteering is not all done by white landlords. There are men of both races who have a reputation for fairness. There are colored operators who have performed a public service to their race in addressing themselves to the extreme problem of shelter, but there are colored owners of houses who charge just as high rents as do white owners. Investigation shows that taking advantage of the colored people, or making money out of them; is not a white monopoly.
How, it will be asked, do Negroes find money to pay these rents? By strategy, and taking their own part. They do it by going without other things. They cut down on fun, food and clothing, and stretch what money they have to cover the rent. But they have other tricks. One is the "rent party." This is a popular form of diversion in Harlem. It goes by the name of the "social parlor." A person invites friends in for the evening, to dance and have a good time, and charges them twenty-five cents a couple; that is one way of getting help to meet the monthly rent bill. Another is to take in lodgers. Lodgers are legion in Harlem. The State Housing Commission told of one apartment properly accomodating about ten persons that was occupied by forty-four. Harlem has gone to the extreme of the double shift. One room is not infrequently let out to two people, one of whom occupies it at night and the other during the day.
THE moment one begins to inquire about exploitation in Harlem, he hears about cabarets. In Harlem there are cabarets to which both white and colored people are admitted. There are cabarets where white and colored sit at the same table, dance together, talk together, drink together, leave together. Many flashy young people of both colors come to these and get riotously or near riotously merry; some less flashy people come; and some sober and sedate folk sit at the tables. All told there are about fifteen cabarets in Harlem. A few cater only to the well-behaved, others to the less well-behaved, and some to roughnecks Two or three of the better places are now the resorts of downtown specialists in the latest places of interest.
No doubt people are fleeced a bit in paying for their entertainment, no doubt some people are swept along pretty rapidly on a current of erotic pleasure, a current of uncertain direction and ambiguous goal. But they come there of their own accord; they seek the cabaret. As an instrument of exploitation the cabaret does not touch many people. Its scope is the.scope of a retreat for devotees.
Another subject often mentioned in connection with exploitation is prostitution. I am aware of no way of proving that the Negro is sexually more or less moral than other people. If there is any exceptional organized assault upon the continence of Negro women, I do not know of it.
LET us turn now to the gentle subject of hooch. Harlem is hooch-ridden. He is a bold man who will undertake to say what part of a city like New York, with its many congested foreign and native quarters, is the wettest. The wash of the booze sea has not left Harlem out; that district may well claim a deeper inundation than any other.
Those syndicates, or firms, or companies, or combinations, that set you up in business as a druggist, equipping you with the white jars and other colorful stock of a druggist's shelves, in order that behind your counters you may run a hooch dispensary, have lined Lenox and Seventh Avenues with such fake establishments. These sell rivers of bad booze to the colored residents of Harlem. There are excellent drug stores in Harlem, but these are drug stores only in name. They have small stocks and cannot fill prescriptions adequately. They specialize in synthetic gin and bad whiskey. Practically all of these places are owned by white people.
There are syndicates also that fit you out with the window displays and front rooms of delicatessen stores.
"A Negro clerk who works in a drug store on Lenox Avenue came running in to me the other day," a competent colored pharmacist in Harlem said to me. "He said: 'A friend of mine brought this prescription into my store. I can't fill it. You fill it for me. If he'd been a stranger, I'd have given him something. But I don't want to hand out to a friend that stuff we have on our shelves.' He didn't bother much with prescriptions, he confessed. Sometimes he put in substitute ingredients; sometimes he left out something that was called for. 'You leave your label off this and I'll put ours on' he said."
The Negro pharmacist continued:
"Some of these drug stores certainly are fakes. Why, they don't keep enough drugs on hand to fill simple prescriptions. Not long ago I sent three prescriptions out to fifteen of 'em--easy prescriptions; I just wanted to make a little experiment. I didn't bother with those drug stores over on Lenox Avenue--I knew what I'd be gettin' into there. I just stuck to Seventh Avenue.
"Well, you should have seen the collection that came back. One prescription called for a nerve sedative, a compound of chloral hydrate, tincture canabis and some other things. Two druggists put elixir of lactated pepsin--for indigestion!--into the prescription, instead of the elixir triple bromides I called for. And you should have seen those bottles! Some were half choked with gelatinous substances that had no business there; others had sediment. They were every color from yellow to dark brown. Why, those druggists just put in any old thing. Another prescription called for a seven-grain capsule. The capsules that came back weighed all the way from three grains to ten; the average was about four. They couldn't even get the quantity right! Those stores are a crime. 'Anything's good enough for niggers!' say the people who run them."
There are other forms of hooch joints--cigar stores, small restaurants, saloon-like shops, delicatessen stores and the like. The drinks they sell are very bad; it is commonly declared that the worst of the illegal booze is worked off on the Negro. These places have been exposed. Their addresses have been published time and again. The owner of The New York Age, Fred R. Moore, already referred to, is a fighting Negro. He is educated and intelligent. He believes in protecting his people from exploitation. Every week for months he has been publishing in his weekly a list of addresses; over it he puts the headline: Old and New Hooch Joints in Harlem. I know of no publication of a similar list of addresses elsewhere.
Sometimes Mr. Moore puts his list on the front page; it runs to about a hundred addresses. Here is part of the list on one street, taken from the issue of October 25, 1924: 404, 414, 419, 434, 448, 452, 481, 476, 477, 486, 488a--eleven within a single hundred numbers. Mr. Moore has never been the defendant in a libel action for characterizing these places as illegally engaged in selling liquor, and that fact is pretty good evidence that they are really what he calls them.
THE Negro in Harlem, like Negroes in many other places, is prey for poorly-trained white doctors and for unmistakable quacks. Some of these come to Harlem because they know that here quackery is easy; they fatten on the credulity of the Negro, and on his faith in the white man. Many of these doctors are prominent members of the community; a population of 200,000 spreads out before them. offering a lucrative field, and they take advantage of it.
Not long ago a white doctor in Harlem dismissed a colored patient, telling him that he had "spider cancer" at the base of his spine, and that it was incurable. Now, there is no such thing as spider cancer. The man had come to the doctor because he had hurt his back in a fall. The doctor applied dressing after dressing and plaster after plaster, and finally produced a creased, web-like spot on the man's back; it was this that he called "spider cancer." The poor fellow received proper treatment only when he went to a trained colored physician in the neighborhood.
"We know some of our white colleagues by their trails," said a colored physician, attached to the out-patient department of Harlem Hospital, to me. He was unwilling to be quoted if the names of these doctors were to be used, and so I have substituted letters for their names. "There's Doctor X, for instance. He is known by the plasters he leaves behind him. Whenever a patient has a pain, X puts a plaster over it. If you raise the shirt of a patient and find a plaster of mole skin adhesive there, you can say, 'Oh, I see you've been to Doctor X.' He always uses mole skin adhesive.
"Then there's Doctor Y. He uses pills, rotating them by color. 'What color did I give you last time ?' he asks his patients, and then changes to another. It's easy to follow Doctor Y; just look at the mantlepiece and if his pills are there, you know what your patient has been up against.
"Doctor Z flops down on his knees and prays and prays with his patients. Though white, he knows his colored people, or a certain class of them. He will blare out in fine style his appeals to the Lord to help the treatment he has just given. I guess prayer is often necessary.
"Then there's Doctor A. 'What!' exclaimed Doctor A. 'Read medical books! I haven't read a medical book for ten years. I don't have to read 'em to practice on niggers!'
"They charge some of these colored people pretty high fees, too. The other day a white doctor charged $600 for drawing the water off a patient who had pleurisy--aspirating, it is called. This is ordinarily done by a physician in the course of a routine call. This doctor called it 'a major operation' and collected $600. They play on the Negro's ignorance of what is being done to him, and rob him."
ALL this, it can readily be imagined, has none too good an effect upon the Negro's health.
Any improvement that the race makes is made despite great obstacles. We all have heard that the Negro is not a healthy race. In a measure, this is true. Tuberculosis is the great enemy of the Negro. In the long run it kills one out of every six; few races show a greater tuberculosis deathrate. The incidence of rickets, a disease of malnutrition among children, is also high with the Negro. Chronic degenerative diseases, such as cerebral hemorrhage and organic diseases of the heart, are strong among Negroes. Cancer and diabetes carry off large numbers of them. The deathrate for the race as a whole is high, especially in cities.
In 1921 the deathrate among Negroes in the rural parts of registration states was 13.8 per 1,000; it was 10.8 for whites. In the cities it was 19.7 for Negroes, 11.8 for whites. Mortality among Negroes, 30 per cent higher than that among whites in the rural parts, was 67 per cent higher in the cities. In New York City the deathrate for Negroes in 1923 was 20.85, for whites 11.25. It looks as if the Negro were paying an unnecessarily heavy toll to the city by being unadapted to climatic conditions, or to prevailing industries, or to the housing available, or to all.
But what has the Negro been doing about this? He has been showing the world how a race can improve in health. His record is amazing. It is as if the Negro had said, "Come, we will be a bigger, better und physically more perfect race," and then had achieved it. Not long ago, Louis I. Dublin, statistician of the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, published facts concerning health among the two million colored policyholders of that company; here is a group large enough to be representative and they live chiefly in towns and cities. From 1911 to 1923Ñtwelve yearsÑthe deathrate for tuberculosis among these policyholders fell from 418 per 100,000to 246, a startling improvement In this same period the deathrate the Negro is not improving in health? The four cornmunicable diseases of childhood--measles, scarlet fever, whooping-cough and diphtheria--together show a decline of 33 per cent; there was a drop of more than 50 per cent in the mortality rates from diarrhea and enteritis among young colored children. The mortality rate for colored children under fifteen years was 10.1 per l,000 in 1911; in 1923 it was only 5.5. "Colored mothers," writes Mr. Dublin, "have not been slow to learn how to care for and feed their babies in accordance with the best practice of the day."
Translate these figures into terms of life expectancy. In 1911 the Negro in this country--considering the Metropolitan figures as representative--was enjoying an average expectation of life of slightly more than forty-one years. In 1923 he was enjoying an expectation of nearly forty-seven years. In the short space of twelve years the Negro added six years to the length of time he had reason to expect to live, an astounding improvement.
The Negro's life expectancy to-day is just about that of the white people of the United States thirty or forty years ago; he is only a generation behind. He is where a number of European countries were just before the Great War. The mortality rate from tuberculosis is beginning to look like that among whites only twenty years ago, when the anti-tuberculosis campaign was begun. A race still living under primitive conditions in many places and often from hand to mouth has done this. "The Negro in America has proved himself thoroughly capable of profiting from the public health campaign," says Mr. Dublin.
All the more disheartening, then, are the difficulties to which attention has been called. The Negro in the Northern city lives in restricted areas of great congestion; he is elbowed and crowded by people of his own and the white color; he knows the evils of bad housing and often of bad sanitation and even squalor; he is set upon by quacks, tricked by fake druggists, fed every form of vile nostrum and vicious patent remedy concocted by man. "Anything is good enough for niggers" is the motto of too many white doctors, druggists, dentists, practitioners of all sorts who infest the colored districts and who have deliberately flocked thither as the colored population has grown.
The Negro has come to the Northern city and the exploiter, the conscienceless sucker of other people's welfare, has risen in his midst.
May it be as a result of these conditions that the improvement just noted has already suffered a set-back in some cities? In Chicago in 1923 the mortality rate was 27 per cent higher than in 1921; in Detroit it was 23 per cent higher. Has the Negro found that in health the Northern city is inhospitable? Have congestion and other difficulties reached a point at which they are beginning to take toll? The effect of the Northern city upon the Negro will bear watching.