

Brown compiled this list of Liberian immigrants from passenger manifests and from ship lists published in the African Repository, the journal of the American Colonization Society. According to Brown, documenting the names of the travelers and obtaining information about them was a difficult project because of the "internal difficulties of the Colonization society" and its "haphazard" record keeping (i).
Here, we have compiled from Brown's work a list of all of the immigrants from Virginia entered on the passenger manifest for the December, 1856 voyage of the M. C. Stevens. Most of the passengers on that ship seem to have been part of the Terrell group, though there are a few groups of passengers who are not mentioned in any of the Terrell letters (i. e. the James, the Norfleets, and the Powells). Not included here are the passengers from states other than Virginia.
Brown's list provides the name, age, state, status (emancipated, free, or purchased), education, and occupation. The education and occupation of all of the Terrell immigrants are unknown.
| Name | Age | State | Status | Education | Occupation |
| Alice | 01 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Congo | 00 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Charles Barrett | 13 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Dick Barrett | 33 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Ellen Barrett | 07 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Francis Barrett | 29 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| James Barrett | 02 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Maria Barrett | 31 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Richard Barrett | 10 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Soloman Barrett | 04 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Young Barrett | 48 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Wiley Bruce | 45 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Ann Carr | 07 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Elizabeth Carr | 02 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Emily Carr | 01 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Maria Carr | 05 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Mildred Carr | 27 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Samuel Carr | 44 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Allen Coleman | 16 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Frank Coleman | 12 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Granville Coleman | 04 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Hunter Coleman | 09 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Maria Coleman | 07 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Martin Coleman | 18 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Washington Coleman | 20 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Wilson Coleman | 22 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Billy Douglass | 42 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Molly Douglass | 12 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Susan Douglass | 41 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| William Douglass | 42 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Arner Fletcher | 50 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Dick Franklin | 64 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Henry Franklin | 31 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Milly Franklin | 60 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Warner Franklin | 34 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Albert Harden | 03 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Carter Harden | 04 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| James Harden | 06 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| John Harden | 30 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Judy Harden | 26 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Sylla Harden | 09 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| James Howell | 01 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Frances James | 35 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Jinny James | 11 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Lavinia James | 14 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Lucy James | 70 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Wilford James | 40 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Isabella Johnson | 15 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Rachel Mann | 19 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| John Michie | 28 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Patrick Michie | 56 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Washington Michie | 23 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Isaac Moore | 50 | VA | Purchased | Unknown | Unknown |
| Lucy Nelson | 04 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Welford Nelson | 00 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Willis Nelson | 08 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Lewis Norfleet | 41 | VA | Purchased | Unknown | Unknown |
| Stella Norfleet | 53 | VA | Purchased | Unknown | Unknown |
| Amanda Powell | 00 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Catharine Powell | 50 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Friday Powell | 03 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Henry Powell | 12 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Levia Powell | 14 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Malinda Powell | 09 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| John Powell | 19 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| William Powell | 07 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| David Scott | 37 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Douglass Scott | 20 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| James Scott | 22 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Margaret Scott | 19 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Mary Scott | 18 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| MaryAnn Scott | 05 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Robinson Scott | 44 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Syphax Scott | 70 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Thomas Scott | 41 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Thomas Scott | 10 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Tibby Scott | 50 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Adeline Southall | 27 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Samuel Thompson | 63 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| William Thompson | 50 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Charles Twine | 24 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Jacob Twine | 55 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Lucy Twine | 19 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Phil Twine | 21 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Betty Walker | 16 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| George Walker | 21 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Hugh Walker | 46 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Hugh Walker | 20 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| MaryJane Walker | 11 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Patty Walker | 39 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Rebecca Walker | 14 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Richard Walker | 02 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Sally Walker | 09 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Winslow Walker | 19 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Zachary T. Walker | 07 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |
| Horace Winston | 06 | VA | Emancipated | Unknown | Unknown |